| Platinum | Rustic Scoops Ice Cream Bar |
| Gold | Daisy Fox Bakery |
| Silver | Petrolia Street Bakery |
| Bronze | Cassie's Cottage |
| Top Pick | Hodgepodge Cakes |
| Top Pick | Indulgence Cheesecakes |
| Top Pick | Junior Baker |
| Top Pick | Sticky Fingers |
| Top Pick | The Bagel Factory |
| Top Pick | Williams Pastry Shop |