| Platinum | Davy Jones Quality Meats |
| Gold | Weiland Meats Market |
| Silver | Navelli's European Delicatessen |
| Silver | Stafford Brothers Meats |
| Bronze | Alfie's European Deli |
| Top Pick | Dresden Meat Packers |
| Top Pick | Sunripe Freshmarket |
| Top Pick | The Country Butcher |
| Top Pick | Vick's Corner Deli |