| Platinum | Rustic Scoops Ice Cream Bar |
| Gold | Suzy's Ice Creamporium/ Original Albert's |
| Gold | The Ice Creamery |
| Silver | Crystal's Ice Cream Shack |
| Silver | Dairy Queen |
| Silver | Ice Cream Galore |
| Silver | Utterly Ridiculous |
| Silver | Yogurtz |
| Bronze | Olde Post Office Gift Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Bubbles Ice Cream |